Monticello Real Estate

Monticello Real Estate

Welcome to Monticello, New York – a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Sullivan County. Known for its rich history and vibrant community, Monticello offers a unique blend of small-town charm and modern conveniences. This picturesque town is surrounded by the breathtaking beauty of the Catskill Mountains, making it an ideal destination for nature lovers and outdoor enthusiasts alike.

Monticello is often recognized as the gateway to the Catskills, providing easy access to a variety of recreational activities. Whether you enjoy hiking, fishing, or simply soaking in the stunning landscapes, the area’s natural beauty is sure to captivate you. In the winter months, nearby resorts offer skiing and snowboarding, ensuring year-round adventure for residents and visitors.

The town is also home to a rich cultural scene, with local festivals, art galleries, and theaters that celebrate the vibrant spirit of the community. Monticello's historic downtown area features charming boutiques and delightful eateries, where you can savor local cuisine and discover unique treasures.

Families will appreciate the strong sense of community and excellent school systems that Monticello has to offer. With a variety of parks and recreational facilities, there are plenty of opportunities for children to play and grow.

Living in Monticello means embracing a lifestyle that balances tranquility with accessibility. Just a short drive from larger urban centers, residents enjoy the best of both worlds – a peaceful retreat with the conveniences of city life within reach. Discover your perfect home in Monticello, where community, nature, and opportunity come together harmoniously.

Newest Listings in Monticello

$2,495,000
5 Beds 5 Baths 1049043 MLS
Welcome to 129 Starlight Road - a new 5,500-square-foot modern lake home combining breathtaking views, architectural design, and the grandeur of true lakefront living. Anchored by 78 feet of private, pristine beach and your own dock, the estate commands unobstructed west-facing views across miles of shimmering water to a forever-protected, rugged forest shoreline. All year long, your day ends with marbled sunsets over the water. Three thirty-foot glass atriums capture the golden-hour light, framing panoramic sunsets. Spanning 4,000 square feet across two main levels - complemented by a 1,500-square-foot windowed recreational attic - the layout balances grand open-concept gathering with serene retreats. Five generously proportioned bedrooms include two dedicated primary suites and three en-suite baths. In total, four full bathrooms and one powder room are meticulously appointed. At the heart of the main floor, the expansive great room anchors the residence, framed by a 55-inch Superior linear gas fireplace and a soaring glass facade. European tilt-turn windows capture the vistas, while massive lift-and-slide glass doors extend living onto the outdoor deck. Extra-long engineered white-oak flooring stretches in 7.7-inch-wide planks across social areas, transitioning to 5-inch planks in bedrooms. The chef’s kitchen includes a windowed breakfast nook and an 8.5-by-4.5-foot island with honed quartz countertops with waterfall edges. Custom solid-wood cabinetry in a pencil-trim shaker profile pairs with a full-height quartz backsplash and integrated display shelf. A double-sized pantry, wet bar, white fireclay sink with black Kohler faucet, and integrated recycling make this space both functional and refined. The 48-inch induction range with exterior-vented hood, counter-depth smart refrigerator, Emerald Series dishwasher, Sharp microwave drawer, and dedicated Summit wine refrigerator provide power, precision, and style. Bathrooms are crafted as spa retreats. Both primary baths feature double-head Lentz thermostatic showers in brushed gold (the upper primary suite also includes a luxurious 69-inch freestanding soaking tub) and 60-inch double vanities. The detached 825 sq ft garage is built to custom marine specs: 28 feet deep with 10-foot ceilings and twin 12-by-10-foot doors to accommodate trailered boats with swim platforms attached and towers raised. Life on the water unfolds across 78 feet of private beachfront, a dock, and a dedicated boat ramp. Steps from the shore, three lake-level bays provide dry, climate-ready storage for skis, surfboards, kayaks, canoes, and life jackets. Spanning 889 acres, nine miles in length, Swinging Bridge Reservoir is an uncrowded haven for waterskiing, wakeboarding, surfing, and jet skiing. Two full-service marinas provide dock maintenance, fuel, and storage. At dawn and dusk, glass-like waters invite paddleboarding and kayaking into secluded coves. Prime fishing awaits offering exceptional seasonal angling and fine ice fishing. Outdoor living spaces include four balconies, two bluestone decks with glass railings, stone-capped foundation walls, a hot tub, outdoor hot-and-cold shower, kitchen hookups, a circular driveway, and landscaped grounds. Engineered for efficiency, radiant heating warms the entire ground-floor slab, backed by dual-fuel, dual-zone furnaces and heat-pump air conditioning. Dual ERV systems circulate filtered fresh air. The exterior pairs thermally modified pine and custom steel-panel cladding beneath a Budmat Iron Click steel roof. Equipped with 300-amp electrical service, Starlink internet, smart-home wiring, five security cameras, biometric Wi-Fi entry, and EV-charger readiness. Just 90 miles from the George Washington Bridge, this estate offers immediate proximity to Bethel Woods Center for the Arts, Resorts World Catskills, The Eldred Preserve, and much more.

129 Starlight Road, Monticello

$2,200,000
1049341 MLS
SALE IS FOR BUILDING ONLY - BUSINESS IS RELOCATING Excellent opportunity to own a substantial, well-built commercial property located directly on Broadway in the heart of the Village of Monticello. Offering approximately 21,000 sq. ft. of versatile commercial space on 2.23 acres, this property is currently utilized as an office supply business, warehouse and offers tremendous potential for a variety of commercial uses. The building features extensive warehouse space with high ceilings, concrete floors, and several overhead doors providing convenient access for deliveries, loading, and distribution. In addition to the warehouse areas, the property includes approximately six to eight private offices, three bathrooms, and ample space that can be configured to accommodate a wide range of business operations. Served by municipal water and sewer, the property also offers a large parking area with plenty of on-site parking for employees, customers, and commercial vehicles. Its combination of office, warehouse, and storage space makes it well suited for distribution, light manufacturing, wholesale operations, contractors, service businesses, retail, storage, or an owner-user looking for a substantial commercial facility. Centrally located on Broadway, the property is within walking distance of restaurants, shopping, public transportation, Village Hall, and other local businesses and services. With approximately 21,000 sq. ft., 2.23 acres, excellent access, and a highly visible Monticello location, this is a unique opportunity for an investor or business owner seeking a large and adaptable commercial property in Sullivan County.

369 E Broadway, Monticello

$749,000
4 Beds 4 Baths 1048684 MLS
This sprawling ranch sits on a spacious corner lot of just over 1.5 acres, surrounded by mature trees and professional landscaping that gives the property a peaceful, tucked-away feel. With 4 bedrooms, 3 full baths, and more than 2,700 sq ft all on one level, the home offers plenty of room to settle in and enjoy comfortable everyday living. Inside, the recently updated kitchen brings a fresh, modern touch to the heart of the home. The partially finished basement gives you extra room for additional living space, workouts, hobbies, or casual hangouts. A wood stove adds cozy warmth, and solar panels (2022) help keep energy costs down. Out back, the property truly shines. The heated pool features a heat pump, auto vac system, and a half bath and bar right by the pool, perfect for easy summer entertaining. The yard includes a premium swing set, a trampoline, and wide-open lawn space for play, gatherings, or simply relaxing outdoors. With a private well and septic, an attached 714 sq ft garage, and both covered and open porch areas, the home blends comfort, convenience, and great outdoor living. The neighborhood is quiet, friendly, and easy to walk, with nearby community spots and everyday essentials close enough to reach without getting in the car. A warm, updated ranch on a beautiful corner lot with a standout pool setup and an incredible yard is ideal for full-time living, a summer home, or a weekend escape. This home is in the perfect location and will not last long. Make your appointment today. Additional photos will be added shortly.

3 Jacob Drive, Monticello

$950,000
1047890 MLS
Opportunities like this are rare. This prime development property is ideally located between Route 42 and the bustling Monticello shopping district, offering excellent visibility, accessibility, and significant commercial potential. The property is strategically positioned on Lanahan Road between two signalized intersections: one on Route 42, directly across from the new Garnet Medical Center, and the other on Anawana Lake Road, across from Walmart. With substantial road frontage, access to public sewer, and favorable terrain, this site offers an exceptional setting for a wide range of commercial development opportunities. Potential uses include retail, restaurants, lodging, automotive dealerships, medical services, movie theaters, and more, subject to zoning and approvals. Access and egress connect to Route 42, and the property is directly behind Taco Bell, two banks, KFC, a bakery, and a gas station. Across the road at Thompson Square are major retailers and services including Home Depot, ShopRite, Starbucks, Five Below, Marshalls, Popeyes, AutoZone, and more. The property is also conveniently located near additional banks, gas stations, Dunkin’ Donuts, McDonald’s, Burger King, and other established businesses. Its proximity to the NY Route 17 / Interstate 86 exit ramps provides convenient regional access and further enhances the site's commercial appeal. The property is located within the HC-2 Highway Commercial 2 District, which permits a variety of potential commercial uses. Please refer to the attached zoning chart for permitted uses and additional requirements. A highly visible location, strong surrounding retail presence, excellent accessibility, public sewer availability, and flexible commercial zoning make this a compelling development opportunity in the heart of the Monticello market.

59 Lanahan Road, Monticello

$1,295,000
2 Beds 2 Baths 1045159 MLS
For those who believe the garage is the most important room in the house, welcome to Motor Club Estates. Set within the exclusive Monticello Motor Club community, this beautifully appointed two-bedroom, two-bath condo offers a rare combination of sleek and modern comfort, serious car storage, and a front-row seat to the Catskills’ most distinctive lifestyle destination. Offered fully furnished and move-in ready, the residence makes an effortless weekend escape or full-time home base. However the real showstopper may be right outside: a private garage with two installed lifts and capacity to accommodate up to eight cars - an exceptional setup for the car collector, enthusiast, or anyone whose idea of a well-appointed upstate escape includes ample for the collection. To keep your driving physique in tip-top shape, a fully equipped gym and indoor pool are right outside the condo’s front door. The Monticello Motor Club brings the country-club concept into decidedly higher gear. Its professionally designed circuit features 4.1 miles of race-grade asphalt, with a 3.6-mile Full Course offering 20 turns and 450 feet of elevation change. Club offerings include professional driving instruction, access to a high-performance fleet featuring BMW, Porsche, and Mazda race cars, karting, off-road experiences, vehicle maintenance and storage, and concierge services. Beyond the track, Monticello Motor Club offers the polish of a private club, with a member clubhouse overlooking the start/finish area, farm to table dining featuring seasonal Hudson Valley and Catskills specialities, private locker rooms, trackside viewing areas, event spaces, and a 16,000-square-foot Collector Car Gallery. Whether you're chasing lap times, collecting cars, or simply looking for an exceptionally fun Catskills escape, this is upstate living with a little more horsepower. Arrive, unpack, garage the toys, and enjoy. Vroom vroom!

11 Serenity Lane Unit #1A, Monticello

Start Your Search
board logo

© 2026 TReND. All Rights Reserved.
The data relating to real estate for sale on this website appears in part through the TReND Internet Data Exchange (IDX) program, a voluntary cooperative exchange of property listing data between licensed real estate brokerage firms in which Real Broker NY LLC participates, and is provided by TReND through a licensing agreement. Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than Real Broker NY LLC are marked with the IDX icon and detailed information about each listing includes the name of the listing broker.
All information provided is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed. Some properties which appear for sale on this website may no longer be available because they are under contract, have sold or are no longer being offered for sale. The information being provided is for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing.

Listings courtesy of OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID. Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of . All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information.