Forestburgh Homes with Monticello School district

Welcome to Forestburgh, New York – a hidden gem nestled in the picturesque Sullivan County. Known for its breathtaking landscapes and serene atmosphere, Forestburgh offers a perfect blend of natural beauty and community charm. This quaint town is surrounded by lush forests, sparkling lakes, and rolling hills, making it an ideal retreat for nature lovers and outdoor enthusiasts alike. From hiking trails to fishing spots, every corner of Forestburgh invites you to explore the great outdoors.

One of the standout features of this beautiful area is its connection to the highly regarded Monticello School District. Families looking to settle down in Forestburgh will appreciate the quality education and supportive environment that the Monticello School District provides. With a strong emphasis on academic excellence and a variety of extracurricular activities, parents can rest assured that their children are receiving a well-rounded education.

The real estate market in Forestburgh is as diverse as its landscape, offering a range of homes that cater to various lifestyles and budgets. Whether you’re searching for a cozy cabin, a charming cottage, or a spacious family home, you’ll find properties that embody the spirit of this enchanting town. Many homes feature stunning views, ample outdoor space, and modern amenities, ensuring a comfortable and enjoyable living experience.

Living in Forestburgh means embracing a tranquil lifestyle while still being conveniently located near the vibrant amenities of Sullivan County. With its welcoming community, excellent schools, and beautiful surroundings, Forestburgh is not just a place to live – it’s a place to thrive. Come discover the magic of Forestburgh, where your dream home awaits!

Newest Forestburgh Homes with Monticello School district

$349,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1044731 MLS

Welcome to 227 Rod and Gun Club Road in Forestburgh, a 3-bedroom, 2-bath ranch offering 1,352 square feet of single-level living on 5 private acres. Surrounded by mature trees and open lawn, this property offers a peaceful setting with plenty of privacy and room to enjoy country living. Inside, you'll find a comfortable layout with three bedrooms, two full baths, and a home ready to welcome its new owners. Several meaningful improvements have been completed, including a brand-new roof, fresh paint throughout the house and a recently painted expansive rear deck. The oil-fired boiler was thoroughly cleaned and inspected in April 2026, and a whole-house backup generator is included with the property. The full unfinished basement offers a largely open footprint with plenty of room for storage, hobbies, a workshop, or recreation. Outside, the expansive rear deck provides plenty of space for entertaining, relaxing, or simply enjoying the surrounding property. With 5 private acres and a peaceful wooded setting, there is room to spread out, enjoy the outdoors, and appreciate the privacy this property provides. Offering acreage, privacy, recent improvements, flexible space, and a quiet Forestburgh setting, 227 Rod and Gun Club Road is ready to welcome its next owners. Come experience the property and imagine calling it home.

227 Rod And Gun Club Road, Forestburgh

$399,900

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1042532 MLS

The lake sets the tone here from the moment you arrive. Tucked along the edge of Forestburgh Pond in scenic Sullivan County, this inviting 2 bedroom, 2 bathroom cottage blends rustic character with everyday comfort in a setting that feels made for slowing down. Whether you are looking for a full time home, a weekend escape, or a potential short term rental opportunity, this property offers a rare chance to enjoy waterfront living in a peaceful, wooded setting. Set directly on the pond, the home offers private water access, wide pond views, and the kind of quiet that makes you want to stay a little longer. Spend your days kayaking, canoeing, fishing, or simply relaxing by the water’s edge. Inside, the open living space is filled with natural light and warm cottage charm, with vaulted ceilings, a stone fireplace, and large picture windows that keep the water in view. The kitchen brings together charm and function with butcher block countertops, open shelving, stainless steel appliances, and a cozy dining nook that feels just right for morning coffee. The primary bedroom features an en suite bath with modern fixtures and a walk in shower, while the second bedroom sits comfortably near the second full bath, making it easy for guests. Hardwood floors, in unit washer and dryer, and ample storage add to the home’s comfort and practicality. Outside, the spacious wraparound deck is made for dining outdoors, stargazing, or simply taking in the stillness of the surroundings. A gently sloping lawn leads to your own private pondside space, and the fire pit area with Adirondack chairs creates the perfect place to end the day. You are also close to some of the area’s favorite destinations, including the Forestburgh Tavern and nearby walking trails, along with the Forestburgh Playhouse, Bethel Woods, and local shops. Just 1.5 hours from NYC, this is the kind of place that works as a primary residence, a weekend retreat, or an income producing getaway, all centered around the simple, timeless pull of the lake.

10 Stag Forest Road, Forestburgh

$790,000

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1033833 MLS

Escape the city and discover the ultimate blend of modern rustic luxury, rich Catskills history, and endless opportunity at 985 Cold Spring Road—an energy-efficient barndominium with sweeping panoramic countryside views. Custom-built in 2017 on 4 private, sun-drenched acres in Forestburgh, NY, this high-capacity organic farmstead occupies the historic landmark site of the former O&W Barnum Train Station. Designed as a turnkey haven for modern homesteading and farm-to-table living, the property features four active greenhouses with automated drip irrigation, gated gardens enriched with Goshen volcanic "black gold" soil, and a fully equipped kitchen with advanced UV filtration ready for food processing or hosting private dinners. Outside, an epoxy-painted concrete porch extends toward the garden, pond, and greenhouses, complete with granite countertops and double sinks ideal for outdoor food processing and entertaining. Inside, spray-foam insulation and solar power combine to offer comfortable year-round living. The main level centers on a climate-controlled open space with soaring ceilings and expansive south-facing, energy-efficient windows that flood the home with natural light. Previously used as a year-round indoor growing studio, this lower level features growing shelves, epoxy floors, a full custom-tiled bathroom, a secondary kitchenette with microwave and dishwasher accented by custom stone and wood finishes, and extensive storage cabinets. The upper level features a wide-open loft with high ceilings, ceiling fans, large windows, and a private terrace offering 360-degree views of the surrounding 4 acres, gardens, pond, and forest—making it ideal for a primary bedroom suite, creative studio, lounge, or home office. This loft level also includes a fully equipped main kitchen and a luxury bathroom featuring a large jacuzzi tub, custom tilework, and a custom vanity. Wake up to sweeping views, fresh air, and the peaceful sounds of nature while enjoying the rewards of a working farm. Located under two hours from New York City and just minutes from Monticello, Resorts World Casino, Holiday Mountain, and Bethel Woods, this rare estate provides an ideal setting for a peaceful weekend retreat, a full-time homestead, or a boutique agritourism venture.

985 Cold Spring Road, Forestburgh

$365,000

1027675 MLS

MOTIVATED SELLER JUST REDOCED build that dream home. acres 9.3 lake front 300 feet secluded private quiet Swinging Bridge Reservoir Nine Miles Long. Lake has two Marinas can have your boat parked at there dock. and storage for the winter. or you can have your own dock in front of your new home. permit small fee. if you do not have your own. you can rent one at the Marina. when friends come to visit. enjoy great food and beverages on the deck overlooking the lake. or step out in the evening at Bethel Woods performing Arts Center or Resort World Catskill Casino and new indoor water park. just 30 minutes is the Delaware River float the river in large rubber rafts. fish. swim. camp. many restaurants dinning over looking the river from their decks. some one once said come up for the week and stay a lifetime.note lot easement restricting clearing to 1 acre between road and buffer/eagle. also between November1 and April1 each year no use of chainsaw construction of boat launches .no tree cutting no use of snowmobiles all tterrain vehicles. in the clove preservation zone. Realtor will provide you on request of the full declaration of restrictions. and the protection of the American Bald Eagles nesting and fly Lains. LAKE IS LINED WITH BEAUTIFUL HOMES PRIVATE QUIET SECLUDED. THE PLACE TO INVEST IN THAT NEW HOME. come up for the week end stay a life time.

Plank Road Forestburg New York, Forestburgh

$249,000

1027736 MLS

Outdoor enthusiasts will appreciate the endless possibilities this property provides: hunting, hiking, ATV riding, and exploring your own woodland sanctuary. A diverse mix of tree conifers and hardwood. Ideally located for those seeking space, privacy, and a connection to nature. Beautiful 4.41 acre parcel offers the perfect opportunity to build your dream home in a truly private setting. The land is predominantly forested and includes a wonderfully secluded building site, ideal for creating a peaceful retreat surrounded by nature. It is gently rolling and has a well and septic. Their is a small outbuilding with electric, an older well and septic where the former home was located. Motivated bring your best offers!

2199 State Route 42, Forestburgh

$799,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1022635 MLS

Welcome to Amanita Lake House, a beautiful retreat completely immersed in nature where peace and quiet takes center stage. From the moment you arrive at this tranquil 5-acre lakefront spot, the only sounds you will hear are the birds singing and the wind rustling through the trees. It is the kind of home that steals your heart right away, offering the ultimate escape from the hustle and bustle, anchored by a dreamy wall of windows that perfectly frames the surrounding wilderness. The outdoor space is a nature lover's dream, featuring two distinct paths down to the spring-fed lake, which is filled with fish and frogs. The first path sits just beyond the house, highlighting the gorgeous views from both the interior and the spacious back deck. This deck comes complete with a handy outdoor shower and stairs leading down to the grassy lawn below. Nearby, you will find a grand firepit built with enormous stones that is perfect for stargazing gatherings, as well as a cozy hot tub lit by string lights to welcome you on cooler nights. The second, more meandering path turns off to the left, lined with mountain laurel that bursts into beautiful spring blossoms and blueberry bushes ripe for picking in mid-summer. This trail leads to an easily accessible part of the waterfront featuring a private dock where you can take a dip or launch your kayak. As a fun bonus, this path also hosts a charming lean-to equipped with a grand tent, just right for a magical glamping night under the stars. Inside, the home exudes a sense of calm with an easy flow and an open floor plan. The great room features a functional kitchen on one end and a cozy living room with a wood-burning fireplace on the other. The central dining area is bathed in natural light filtering through the massive wall of windows. For seamless indoor-outdoor living, two sliding glass doors open out to the deck, while another door off the living room leads to a good-sized screened porch. Tucked away down the hallway are three comfortably sized bedrooms, each with its own closet, and a shared full bathroom featuring wood accents and classic tile work. The lower level, accessed via stairs off the great room, offers a second spacious area that is perfect for lounging. The current owner has set up an additional bed here to easily accommodate overflow guests. This level also includes another fully updated bathroom, a convenient washer and dryer, and direct door access to the backyard. Less than 2 hours from New York City and close to Bethel Woods Center for the Arts.

1289 Plank Road, Forestburgh

$269,000

1023864 MLS

Discover a rare opportunity to build your dream retreat on 2 pristine lakefront acres in the sought-after Lake Joseph community. This quiet, non-motorboat lake offers unmatched tranquility and a true connection to nature. Direct access to Lake Joseph, ideal for kayaking, canoeing, paddleboarding. Peaceful fishing in calm, clear waters, frequent eagle sightings and abundant wildlife. Private, wooded setting with exceptional views. Outdoor pool, Tennis Court, Basketball court and hiking trails throughout the community. Minutes to top regional destinations: The Motor Club, Resort World Catskill, Bethel Woods Performing Arts Center, The Forestburgh Playhouse. Whether you envision a weekend escape or a full-time lake home, this property delivers the ideal blend of privacy, recreation, and convenience in one of Forestburgh’s most desirable lake communities. HOA rules in documents.

Lena Road, Forestburgh

$650,000

1022571 MLS

This 84.95 acre property can be your own private secluded oasis, surrounded by 6,580 acres of New York State DEC protected land known as the Neversink River Unique Area. Perfect for hiking, hunting, four wheeling, or just enjoying nature in peace and privacy. Take a relatively short hike down the Wilderness Trail to the Fish Hatchery Trail leading to the Neversink River. Gated entrance from Wilderness Trail and accessible from the adjoining properties at 225 Hatchery Road and 242 Denton Falls Road. This special property consists of three separate lots for sale individually that could be purchased together totaling nearly 300 acres (298.09 acres). Just a short drive from the hustle and bustle of New York City, make this your serene hunting and fishing getaway! Get back to nature and live off the grid! A short distance down Hatchery Road brings you access to world-class fly fishing in the beautiful Neversink River. Located near in the foothills of the Catskill Mountains, this makes for an amazing gathering place, potential hunting property, private getaway or Sportsmen's club. Enjoy privacy and seclusion amongst the beauty of nature in the foothills of the Catskill Mountains by the Neversink River. Wilderness Trail (84.95 acres, MLS 1022571) can also be purchased as a package with adjoining properties at 225 Hatchery Rd (5.38 acres, MLS# 1022570) and 242 Denton Falls Rd (207.76 acres, MLS# 1022573) making for a total of 298.09 acres! Here is your opportunity to own this special property!

Wilderness Trail, Forestburgh

$1,100,000

1022573 MLS

207.76 Private Acres Surrounded by Protected NYS DEC Land — Your Private Catskill Mountain Retreat... Incredible opportunity to own 207.76 acres of private land surrounded by 6,580 acres of New York State DEC-protected land known as the Neversink River Unique Area. Located in the foothills of the Catskill Mountains, this exceptional property offers privacy, seclusion, and direct access to some of the region’s most beautiful natural surroundings. This is the largest of three adjoining parcels being offered individually, with the opportunity to purchase all three together for a total of 298.09 acres. The property is bordered to the north by Denton Falls Road and to the east by Wilderness Trail, providing multiple access points. Gated entrances are located along Denton Falls Road and Wilderness Trail, with additional access available from adjoining properties at 225 Hatchery Road and 242 Denton Falls Road. Nature enthusiasts will appreciate the property's proximity to the Neversink River, renowned for world-class fly fishing. Access the river via Wilderness Trail, the Fish Hatchery Trail, and Hatchery Road. Spend the day hiking, fishing, hunting, exploring, or simply enjoying the peace and beauty of this remarkable setting. Just a short drive from the hustle and bustle of New York City, this property offers an ideal opportunity to create a private hunting and fishing retreat, off-grid getaway, private compound, gathering place, or potential sportsmen’s club. Whether you're looking for a secluded escape or a large recreational property, this unique offering provides an extraordinary opportunity to get back to nature. Additional parcels available for purchase: 242 Denton Falls Road — 207.76 acres | MLS #1022573 225 Hatchery Road — 5.38 acres | MLS #1022570 Wilderness Trail — 84.95 acres | MLS #1022571 Purchase all three parcels together for nearly 300 acres — 298.09 acres total. Opportunities to own a property of this size, surrounded by protected land and located near the Neversink River and Catskill Mountains, are truly special. Come experience the privacy, natural beauty, and endless recreational possibilities this exceptional property has to offer.

242 Denton Falls Road, Forestburgh

$700,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1018170 MLS

This modern Colonial, built in 2005, is tucked away in the Catskills on 2.3 private acres—close to shopping, everyday conveniences, and with easy access to Route 17, yet still a world away from the noise and pace of the city. Meticulously maintained and beautifully presented, the home features 4 bedrooms, 3 bathrooms, soaring tall ceilings, an inviting open-concept layout, a chef’s kitchen, and generous entertaining spaces designed for effortless gatherings. Step outside and the expansive property becomes your own private retreat. The backyard is large enough to accommodate a pool, offering even more potential for outdoor enjoyment. Enjoy morning coffee on the porch, unwind beneath the covered gazebo, or savor warm summer evenings under the soft breeze of the overhead fan while taking in the peaceful woodland views. A whole-house generator adds an extra layer of comfort and security, ensuring year-round peace of mind. More than a home, this is a place to slow down, reconnect, and enjoy true tranquility far from the city—while still being just minutes from the town’s shops, dining, and major routes. Recent upgrades include: • Basement Waterproofing System – Perimeter drainage installation – Sump pump system with backup options – Frozen discharge line protection and exterior extension • New 50-Gallon Water Heater – Full replacement and installation – Updated plumbing connections and safety fittings • Lighting & Hardware Upgrades – Replacement of interior lighting fixtures – Updated door hardware throughout the home • Window Treatments – Installation of new blinds for all designated windows • Interior Painting Refresh – Full-house wall and trim repainting – Touch-ups and surface preparation as needed • Security System Readiness – ADT system wireless connection and equipment readiness Book your showing today, all pre-approved buyers welcome.

802 Rose Valley Road, Forestburgh

$699,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1001847 MLS

SPECTACULAR HOME IN FORESTBURGH, NY ON 5 PRIVATE ACRES WITH LAKE RIGHTS - Welcome to this beautifully crafted four-bedroom home, privately nestled in the woods on five serene acres, offering the perfect blend of comfort, style, and country living. A grand entry foyer with a stunning wood staircase sets the tone as you step inside. The spacious layout is designed for both relaxation and entertaining. To the right, you'll find a large living room featuring a wood-burning fireplace for cozy evenings, along with a washroom and 1/2 bath. To the left is an additional living area that flows seamlessly into the dining room and kitchen, creating an inviting and functional living space. The kitchen is truly the heart of the home and a dream for any cook or entertainer. Beautiful cabinetry provides abundant storage, while quartz countertops and expansive prep surfaces make hosting effortless. A commercial-grade KitchenAid gas cooktop completes this impressive space. One of the home's most loved features is the enormous screened-in porch, where you can relax and fully enjoy the peaceful natural surroundings throughout the day. Upstairs offers four generously sized bedrooms, including a spacious primary suite with a beautifully appointed ensuite bath featuring soaking tub. The oversized walk-in closet adds an extra touch of luxury you'll appreciate every day. Outdoor living is equally exceptional, with a large deck and patio area complete with a hot tub for the ultimate retreat experience. The property is surrounded by mature trees and evergreens for year-round beauty, along with open sunny areas ideal for gardens, a fire pit, or even a future pool. Just down the road, the HOA maintains a private members-only lake area with beach access, kayak storage, swimming, fishing, and relaxing lakeside enjoyment. A public access area to Swinging Bridge Reservoir is just down the road. Swinging Bridge is approximately 800 acres, 120' deep with 17 miles of shoreline and offers two marinas for boat rentals/storage and is a fabulous lake for fishing, swimming or storing your jet-ski. Located approximately two hours from NYC and just 20 minutes to NYC train access, this home offers an easy escape from the city while remaining conveniently accessible. Nearby attractions include charming towns for dining and shopping, the Delaware River for rafting and fishing, Bethel Woods Performing Arts Center for concerts under the stars, The Kartrite Indoor Waterpark, Resorts World Catskills Casino, skiing at Holiday Mountain and Big Bear at Masthope, scenic hiking and biking trails, and some of the best farmers markets in the region. Experience the beauty and tranquility of country living at its finest.

203 Wildwood Way, Forestburgh

$1,275,000

5 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ 980987 MLS

Serenity and Charm built within the storied walls of this Queen Anne style home adorned with shake shingle exterior, overlooking natures wooded hills and the most perfect lake. The charm of two staircases and cute nook spaces beneath the stairs brings a smile within. Walk in to the most organized coat room and hideaway for all of your "things"..Then..Experience the "heart" of this home..the open design of the dining room with enormous windows with priceless views. The kitchen has a walk in pantry, enormous "hang out" island and so much space for cooking, baking and gatherings.. This home has been gutted, renovated and brought up to perfection. Just waiting for your design eye! The main living room has the most magical oversized stone fireplace you could ever imagine, and a screened in porch for those lazy afternoons sipping your lemonade. On the other side of the home is a sweet main room with views, perfect for puzzles, card games and just hanging. Up the back staircase is the primary suite and getaway living space . From your bed you can look out over the top of the trees and view of the lake. Down the hall are the secondary bedrooms and bathrooms which will ease your mind and gift you much privacy .The yard has a fenced in garden and a wood shed , plus the original tiny garage which is "as is" but everso quaint for storage. A stones throw away is the lake with a long dock to sit on and splash your feet in the lake, plus, a place for your kayak. THAT vision and moment..well deserved. There are clay tennis courts down the road, and an informal nine hole golf course, plus main lake beach area for all. This private club has generational heritage and been hiding in these woods of Forestburgh since 1889. There are thousands of acres owned by the club and are preserved to retain our precious nature. There is an initiation fee and the annual dues includes the maintenance of roads and gifts you all the club offers. Call for your private tour and rare offering to be a part of these historic woods and memories.

57 Inn Road, Forestburgh

Start Your Search

© 2026 TReND. All Rights Reserved.
The data relating to real estate for sale on this website appears in part through the TReND Internet Data Exchange (IDX) program, a voluntary cooperative exchange of property listing data between licensed real estate brokerage firms in which Real Broker NY LLC participates, and is provided by TReND through a licensing agreement. Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than Real Broker NY LLC are marked with the IDX icon and detailed information about each listing includes the name of the listing broker.
All information provided is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed. Some properties which appear for sale on this website may no longer be available because they are under contract, have sold or are no longer being offered for sale. The information being provided is for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing.

Listings courtesy of OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID. Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of . All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information.